StickStar Watching the Ponies: Past Performances. SMU's First Class Is Built on Proven Winners.
Share
In horse racing, the racing form has a section called past performances. It's a horse's record: every start, every finish, every win. You read it before you bet.
On October 30, Jim Mitchell stood at SMU and said the roster was empty. Six days later, the Mustangs announced their "First Class." Thirteen graduate transfers with seven All-American honors, three conference titles, two national championships and 340 career goals.
That's the foundation. Here's what's on it.
First, How This Works
These players are not coming to Dallas this spring. Almost all of them are seniors right now. They'll play the 2027 season at their current schools, then join SMU for their fifth year in 2028, when the Mustangs play their first game.
The Ivy League doesn't let athletes play a fifth year as graduate students. So every spring, a group of the best players in the country has to go somewhere else to finish. SMU athletic director Damon Evans pointed to that group when he announced the program. Then Mitchell went and got it.
Nine of the 13 come from the Ivy League. Three of them played for Mitchell at Princeton.
The First Class
| Player | Pos | From | Hometown | The record |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tucker Wade | M | Princeton | Bethesda, Md. | 2026 first-team All-American (USILA, USA Lacrosse, Inside Lacrosse). National champion. 93 goals and 104 points. Goal in 26 straight games. |
| Ryan Goldstein | A | Cornell | Radnor, Pa. | 2025 national champion. Four goals in the title game. 43 goals and 50 assists in 2025. Multiple All-American honors. |
| Jake Melchionni | LSM | Villanova | Bernardsville, N.J. | Four career All-American honors, including third team from USILA and USA Lacrosse in 2026. Big East Specialist of the Year. |
| Peter Grandolfo | M | Bucknell | Fairfield, Conn. | First-team All-Patriot League in 2026. Three-year starter. 53 goals. |
| Matt Tully | G | Cornell | Foxboro, Mass. | Second-team All-Ivy in 2026. 54.5% save percentage. Ivy Defensive Player of the Week. |
| Matthew Till | LSM | Penn | Bullis (Md.) | Two-time second-team All-Ivy. Wade's high school teammate. |
| Nick Lucchesi | M | Villanova | Radnor, Pa. | 2026 captain. Second-team All-Big East. Overtime winner that sent Villanova to the Big East tournament. |
| Luke Gilmartin | SSDM | Cornell | Syracuse, N.Y. | 2025 national champion. 80 ground balls and 25 caused turnovers in 49 games. |
| AJ Nikolic | M | Cornell | Malvern Prep (Pa.) | 2025 national champion. 6-2 midfielder. 16 goals in 20 games despite injuries. |
| Colin Vickrey | G | Princeton | Southlake youth lacrosse | 2026 national champion. Part of Princeton's No. 1-ranked recruiting class. |
| Carson Krammer | M | Princeton | Mercer Island, Wash. | 2026 national champion. 6-5, 240. Part of Princeton's No. 1-ranked recruiting class. |
| Declan Monahan | G | Penn | Bethesda, Md. | Gonzaga College High School. |
| Max Goldstein | M | Vermont | Vermont reached the America East final in 2026. |
Inside Lacrosse's transfer tracker also lists four more players headed to SMU who weren't in the official announcement: Tyler Fox (Boston U), Ike Lohens (Cornell), Bo Page (Trinity) and Walker Schwartz (Cornell). Page started all 44 games of his career at Trinity, with 86 goals and 49 assists.
The Headliner
Tucker Wade is the name. He was a first-team All-American on a national championship team, coached by the man now building SMU. He scored in every game Princeton played last season. He had two goals in the title game against Notre Dame.
Inside Lacrosse put it simply. Every good team needs an X attackman and a dodging midfielder. SMU's first announcement had both: Goldstein and Wade.
Two Title Teams in One Locker Room
Cornell won the 2025 national championship. Princeton won in 2026. SMU now has seven players from those two teams: four from Cornell (Goldstein, Gilmartin, Nikolic and Tully) and three from Princeton (Wade, Vickrey and Krammer).
Before SMU has played a game, its locker room already has players from the last two national champions.
The Texas Kid
One of the 13 is coming home. Colin Vickrey played youth lacrosse in Southlake, summer ball for Mad Dog National and for Texas Forever, then high school at Culver Military Academy in Indiana, went to Princeton and won a national title.
In 2028, he'll be back in Texas, playing Division I lacrosse in his home state. Until this fall, that wasn't possible.
Why Start With Transfers
SMU doesn't have three years to wait on a high school class. It plays in the ACC in spring 2028, against Duke, Notre Dame, Syracuse, Virginia and North Carolina.
So Mitchell started with players who already know what winning looks like. In SMU's release, he called the First Class "the standard we're establishing for everything we do."
The second step was the class of 2027. That story is next.
Day 34
SMU announced men's lacrosse on October 15. It's been 34 days. In that time:
- October 30: Jim Mitchell named head coach
- November 2: Inside Lacrosse reports the first wave of transfers
- November 5: The First Class is announced
- November 13: Donal Mullane named assistant coach; SMU reaches 10 commits in the class of 2027
Less than three weeks ago, the roster was empty. Now it has a foundation.
Sources: SMU Athletics; Inside Lacrosse (Terry Foy, 11/2 and 11/4); Princeton, Cornell, Villanova, Penn and Bucknell athletics; Dallas Morning News.
Support the Report
The StickStar Report has covered Texas lacrosse for years: the Recruiting Radar, the commits, the programs and the fights worth having. Every StickStar purchase helps keep it going.
![]() ProLine Polo Carolina or Navy with white and red dots · $64.99 |
![]() Navy Bamboo Sun Hoodie Soft bamboo with SPF · $59.99 |

